Whenever Hollywood gets hold of a decent concept, there’s plenty of scope for them to fuck it up something awful. Such is the case with a good portion of comic adaptations. (On a side note, when Hollywood gets hold of a shitty concept, there’s even more scope to produce something so terrible you’d rather gouge out your eyes than watch it. For instance, anything based on a game and directed by Uwe Boll) So whenever someone announces the movie of the comic, you can pretty much hold your breath and brace yourself for a terrible film. Three films based on Alan Moore’s concepts/characters are prime examples of this. The original work is pure unashamed genius. The films, Constantine, From Hell, and the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, are nothing less than a complete affront to all that is good and holy.
Imagine, then, my utter surprise, when V for Vendetta turned out to be one hell of a good film. Not just “good” good, it’s quite likely to be “best film I’ll see this year” good. They’ve changed a good chunk of stuff from the comic, but most of that is about thematically updating things or structurally augmenting it for film. Hugo Weaving puts in a great performance as V, and it works incredibly well, especially since you don’t see his face for the whole film. It’s fucking oscar-worthy. Natalie Portman plays a good Evey in all ways except that ear-shredding accent of hers. Eliza Doolittle watch out. Stephen Fry, John Hurt, basically every actor is giving it their all for every scene, and it’s hard to find fault with any of them. If someone had told me that the film version of V would have the Benny Hill theme in AND that I’d find it hilarious and appropriate, I would probably have sold them out to the government immediately, and yet it does turn out to be hilarious (and simultaneously nauseating, because you know what’s going to happen afterwards…)
I can understand when Alan Moore didn’t like it. I can understand why some fans of the comic will find it a terrible travesty. The pure fact, though, is that if you judge it alone without comparing it to the comic, it’s a slice of genius. It’s a rare situation where the source and derivative works can be surprisingly different but good in their own ways. Unlike THHGTTG which, taken as a film, was a horrible pile of crap. But I always say I’m not going to bash the WORST FILM OF 2005 again. V leaves me with the same kind of feeling that Fight Club left me with at the end. It distills within you the desire to rebel against something and go down in flames, though unfortunately as a middle class white male I am the establishment and as such, any rebelling is likely to be either against myself or highly ignored by everyone else. Though maybe I’ll buy myself a can of spraypaint just in case the chance comes up to use the V symbol. This film has taught me that Grafitti = freedom. The scene where Parliament explodes nearly moved me to tears, that’s the level of awesomeness we’re dealing with, and I’ll be happy to explain to anyone who doesn’t like it why they’re mathematically wrong to hate this film.
(As films of the comics go, it’s up there with Sin City and the Spider-Man films as being enjoyable while retaining the spirit of the original, if not necessarily staying entirely faithful)
We went to see V at the VUE near Park Royal, and as we walked in to the screen, they gave us a bunch of focus-group questionnaires which I found highly amusing, and that I’ll be writing more about tomorrow. Today we went for a Carvery lunch at the New Inn, played some DOA3, and then Josh had downloaded the Sims 2 so I’ve been torturing my own creations in that. Is there no simpler joy than moving a family into a house, deleting the door, and watching the descent begin? I think not.
Recent Comments